What matters in AI.

Subscribe

A New York lawyer says AI providers must pay for agent losses

A lawyer says the AI provider must pay when an agent buys more than the shopper let it buy.

On 18 November 2026, a panel at The Clearing House discussed who pays when an AI agent buys more than the shopper let it buy. Chris Filburn, a lawyer for the Attorney General of New York State, said the AI provider must pay. A Visa test found that AI models had failures in 42.8% of simulated runs.

What each side says

  • Filburn: the shopper owns a purchase that the shopper confirms. The provider owns the loss from an agent that works without a person.
  • Jelena McWilliams of Plaid: banks must let agents in through trusted interfaces. Fraud tools can hold an odd purchase.
  • Kelvin Chen of the Consumer Bankers Association: a US rule makes a consumer liable when a helper does more than the consumer let it do.

The numbers

The Visa November test told models to find the item that a shopper needed. The models had to not buy if nothing fit. They had failures in 42.8% of runs. Filburn said that differences between models can count in disputes.

What is not known

No rule says who pays for this. Carla Sanchez-Adams of the National Consumer Law Center said the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau can make its rules clear. McWilliams thinks that courts and attorneys general in the US will shape these disputes before new federal rules are last.

Insight: Bank limits push the loss toward AI providers

Filburn said that in current law banks can get the loss, and this gives them a cause to limit agents. In October 2026, Citigroup said it does not let third-party agents use customer accounts. This reads as a standoff about who holds the loss: each refusal adds pressure on AI providers to get it. Makers of payment agents can make plans for refusals until liability is clear.

Sources

  1. Panel Weighs Who Pays When AI Agents Exceed Consumers’ InstructionsPYMNTS.com
  2. Panel Weighs Who Pays When AI Agents Exceed Consumers’ Instructionspymnts.com
AI MATTER · NEWS · AI MATTER · NEWS ·19 NOV2026

Posted

Learn the terms in this story

More in Policy

All Policy news